Archive for the ‘Media’ Category

Chinese reporter guilty of bribery

August 9th, 2009 by Johanna | Leave comments | Filed in China, Media

According to American media ethics, good journalists will never accept gifts, money or other sorts of compensation for their work in an attempt to remain unbiased. Thus, I thought it was really qiguai (weird) when my roommate was given 100 yuan for covering a story on kids of government officials. Then a few weeks later, I was sent to cover a press conference and festival opening and given 300 yuan (about $45) from the organizers. It made me more than uncomfortable, but I accepted that this was the Chinese way.

Thus, it was even stranger to read that a reporter from the state-owned CCTV was found guilty of taking bribes from her lover who was the brother of a man under investigation. The Wall Street Journal explained it thus:

China’s criminal law defines the crime of bribery as occurring when “state personnel take advantage of their office to demand money and things from other people” or when they “obtain favors.” In this case, the Shanxi procuratorate’s office successfully argued that Ms. Li was an employee of a government organization, since CCTV is run by the state. However, in practice, it is common for Chinese journalists to receive “red packets” filled with cash for attending press conferences and other corporate events, purportedly to cover their travel expenses.

My cash didn’t come in a hongbao, just a Chinese money envelope. Anyway, I guess in China, it’s OK for the state to bribe reporters. Sometimes I forget how hypocritical and nonsensical China is.

State media taboos

August 5th, 2009 by Johanna | Leave comments | Filed in China, Media, Reflections, Work

I’ve been censored!

I almost made it two whole months!

But finally, it’s happened!

Something I wrote did not fly with the powers-that-be who mine articles for personal opinions at China.org.cn. Unbeknownst to me, I had inserted “personal opinion” into an article I wrote on two Swiss photographers, Mathias Braschler and Monika Fischer. Personal opinion is a huge no-no in traditional journalism. I was pretty embarrassed. (more…)

Xinjiang riots are affecting my life

July 7th, 2009 by Johanna | Leave comments | Filed in China, Current Events, Life, Media

After blocking Twitter yesterday, China seems to have blocked access to Facebook and AIM, as well. At least, I can’t get on them. I can’t find any reports of problems with AIM, but I have no idea why I can’t get on it (Chinese people use MSN Messenger, anyway). It went down around the same time as Facebook, and well, the government makes a great scapegoat.

Jews tamper with the institution of journalism

June 22nd, 2009 by Johanna | Leave comments | Filed in Media

Haaretz, one of Israel’s leading newspapers known for its elitist and liberal readership, tried a bold little experiment earlier this month. It sent 31 of the country’s finest literary authors out to cover the day’s news in lieu of its usual reporting staff.

It’s no secret that the news business is in crisis, which many people say is its own doing. And they’re mostly correct. The world of journalism is a very ugly world. It is full of fact-spouting know-it-alls, who, despite their best intentions, always end up doing what they rail against. Journalists cling to the notion that there is an unbiased and external truth out there, a view that is becoming increasingly at odds with a postmodernist world. Moreover, journalists like to think of themselves somewhat as purveyors of truth, which only adds to their self-delusion and complicates matters. Journalists used to be the link between newsmakers and the masses, but that role has been diminished with the advent of television and the Internet. Now that everyone can see the facts for themselves, who needs reporters to relay information? News has become more and more just the reporter’s truth.

Which brings me back to the Jew story. The Jewish Daily Forward’s report on the experiment included this quote from Yossi Melman, a writer for Haaretz:

“It would be very difficult to replace journalists with authors and run a newspaper. We are trained; we know how to do it. For them, you know, there is a tendency to elaborate.”

None of what he says is wrong. News reporting and news writing is a craft that, like in any other profession, is best done by those who have been trained in it. There is a model, however flawed it is now, that has worked and evolved. But just because we journalists know our trade better than anyone else doesn’t mean inspiration for improvement can’t come from outside sources. A wild idea, admittedly, but perhaps news should become more thought-provoking.

An introduction to the dark side

June 9th, 2009 by Johanna | Leave comments | Filed in China, Media, Reflections, Work

On the surface, China doesn’t feel all that different from the States. Except for the occasional culture shock, I barely notice I’m in a different country. For one thing, my routine is pretty much the same: I wake up, go to work, come home and eventually find dinner somewhere. I ate out all the time back home, and I eat out all the time here. I’m so used to hearing Chinese back home that it goes in one ear here and out the other.

But every once in a while, something comes up to remind me that I am living in a tightly controlled country: The guards standing at every entrance to every parking lot and building. A popular Web site that I can’t access. The six security cameras that watch and record my every move at work.

Then there was an assignment I got for work today. I was asked to look over it and see if I wanted to polish it — if I did, I would receive monetary compensation. A little strange, I thought, considering my manager had been handing me stories all last week to polish without giving me a choice or any money. Then again, she gave my roommate yesterday some cash after he finished a story involving government workers’ kids. The UNC alum who now works for the company told us that this kind of compensation is nothing unusual.

She also once advised that the answer is always yes here. We will be asked if we wanted to do something — go on a trip, participate in a KTV party, polish a story — and the correct answer is yes. After skimming the story in question, though, I wanted to say no. There was something fishy about it. In fact, it wasn’t even a story; it was a fabricated transcript of a discussion on the Falun Gong that allegedly included scholars from all over the world. (more…)