Archive for the ‘Reflections’ Category

Things to take away from China’s birthday party

October 9th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections

Nothing like a good op-ed piece and a national birthday to reawaken my pro-China inclinations. The Grand Parade was certainly magnificent (you can always count on China to put on an over-the-top spectacle), but still super dry and hella boring. The only highlights were:

  1. When, during the flag-raising ceremony, the soldier threw the flag into the air (at about 7:35 in the video). That is just cool.
  2. When the all-female brigade passed by, Hu Jintao cracked a smile for the first time and started applauding. Who doesn’t like hundreds of rifle-toting women in blue uniform dresses marching in a unison bloc?
  3. The nukes. On parade.

As for the op-ed, it should provide a cursory introduction to the fundamental ideas behind China’s actions, as well as a reminder that China does have veritable ideals of its own, fashioned from its millennia of history. They force my mind to bend in ways that my mind can’t (much like physics), but only time will tell if they will deliver. Cynics and critics still have a lot to say about China’s actual adherence and belief in those eight ideas (China’s selection of facts, the CCP’s performance legitimacy belies the party-state it set up), but the PRC is just 60 years old. While it has made some very rapid changes and progress in some areas, it remains — almost frustratingly — slow in reforming other areas.

Thoughts from my balcony

August 11th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections

I’m enjoying the Beijing night one last time from my balcony. I haven’t sat out here in forever, it seems, which makes me realize how long I’ve been here—long enough to undergo changes in behavior. Sitting on the balcony at night right before I went to bed was one of my favorite things about living here. It still is, but Beijing nights are no longer as cool as they used to be when I first got here. Plus we started staying out later, and I usually just went straight to bed after getting home and showering.

Today was actually probably the hottest day that I can recall. Tomorrow is supposed to be just as hot, around 35 degrees Celsius. But it feels nice right now, though not very much breeze. I’ve said this a gajillion times already, but I’m going to say it again: I can’t believe this is it and it’s over. Time flies. It feels like it’s been such a short time, but thinking back to the beginning—what did I know then? How did I imagine this would be?—it was so long ago and different.

Datong: Really is all the same

August 8th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections

Just back from Datong. I need to go meet a friend, though, but here are a few thoughts:

Datong, briefly: It’s nasty and dirty. China is, in general, but Datong is nasty and dirty in a different way. Shanxi is infamous for its coal mines, and the dust from the coal supposedly blankets the whole province. I don’t know if the dust in Datong was coal, though, it was mostly just very fine dirt. I suspect it was everywhere because Datong seemed to be tearing up all of its roads. Everywhere we went, we would drive at least on two really really bumpy dirt roads that looked to be once paved. Our hotel room had a bunch of bugs, including roaches. There also is no ice cream in Datong, which I will elaborate on later.

China, generally: My mini-holidays are over, and the next time I travel somewhere, it will be to go home. Getting out of Beijing has made me realize how spoiled this city has made me, though. Which is interesting to think because of how living in Beijing has made me realize how spoiled the States has made me. Beijing has culture; I mean, it has different people from different backgrounds, and they all clash with each other. At the same time, Beijing is still Beijing, still China, and it is so without losing its identity and history. It is surely changing rapidly, but getting lost in its hutongs will still transport you back in time. Datong was uninspiring, everywhere the same. In Beijing, vendors at markets vary very little, and the whole city of Datong was like that. Every store on a street by our hotel was a little convenience shop (more on this later). Another street was all mian guan (restaurants selling noodles). Of course, Datong is not a big city like Beijing. Perhaps it’s a good sign of progress that China has cities like Beijing, which was so different just 30 years ago. But, though cities are always ahead of the wave, they are not necessarily harbingers of the future.

Heading for the home stretch

August 5th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections, Shenanigans, Work

It’s hard to believe that my summer in Beijing is nearing the end. I leave a week from tomorrow. It’s already August, but I have had no concept of time here. It doesn’t feel like I will be going home soon–probably because I can’t fathom that I’ve already been here for 10 weeks. These weeks have flown, and it seems like I just arrived. And yet, it feels like I’ve been here for forever.

I don’t want to dwell on this too much because it’s making me really sad.

I have been super-uber busy these past couple of weeks. I caught a minor cold a few weeks back and have been recovering since. Chris and I took a long weekend to Dandong, and I just found out yesterday that my uncle has been staying there for the past month or so. We came back, did our last burger story, wrapped up the internship with an evaluation-presentation, celebrated our last day with some coworkers (including a new one, with whom Chris is infatuated), then took off for Qingdao for another long weekend. (More on Qingdao later.) Chris and I returned yesterday evening for his final dinner (hotpot) in China, celebrated in the company of our closest work friends, and then a few rounds of beer. Now he’s gone, and it hasn’t quite hit me.

Tonight, Pang Li and I will try to get tickets to see Up, which just came out here.

Tomorrow, I’m off to Datong with Catherine, the last remaining intern. We plan to come back Saturday.

Catherine heads back to the States on Monday.

Meanwhile, I still have one more hamburger story to write for work and perhaps some stuff on Dandong or Qingdao. I have many, many pictures I need to post.

State media taboos

August 5th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections, Work

I’ve been censored!

I almost made it two whole months!

But finally, it’s happened!

Something I wrote did not fly with the powers-that-be who mine articles for personal opinions at China.org.cn. Unbeknownst to me, I had inserted “personal opinion” into an article I wrote on two Swiss photographers, Mathias Braschler and Monika Fischer. Personal opinion is a huge no-no in traditional journalism. I was pretty embarrassed.

Here is the disputed original. See if you can spot the opinion.

Braschler and Fischer could not dodge the bureaucratic red tape so easily at other times. In Shaanxi Province’s Yan’an to shoot at the only retirement home for revolutionaries of the Chinese civil war, the institution’s director insisted on having official permission to take pictures. Despite the new press freedoms, Braschler and Fischer were forced to seek authorization from the media department of the local government, where they were bounced around from official to official because no one wanted to take the responsibility.

They also were arrested three times. “For no reason—that would not happen in other countries,” Fischer said.

“We’ve never been arrested before, so that was quite a surprise,” Braschler said. “Particularly for us, it [photography] was just the most natural thing we did.”

[Here, I describe the situations that led to their arrests.]

This is what appears in the final version (emphasis added for your convenience):

The photographers faced many other challenges on the road. They battled a respiratory infection, a gastrointestinal infection and three cases of food poisoning. They took countless gambles on where to find hotels or places to stay. In the Taklimakan Desert, near a military nuclear test site, they were allowed to stay at a hotel only after negotiations and on the condition that no one saw them. Foreigners were not allowed in the region without proper paperwork.

Braschler and Fischer could not dodge the bureaucratic red tape so easily at other times. In Shaanxi Province’s Yan’an to shoot at the only retirement home for revolutionaries of the Chinese civil war, the institution’s director insisted on having official permission to take pictures. Despite the new press freedoms, Braschler and Fischer were forced to seek authorization from the media department of the local government, where they were bounced around from official to official because no one wanted to take the responsibility. They also were questioned at the local police station three times by authorities.

In China, it is not exactly an arrest if police show up, take you in their car to the police station and question you for hours before releasing you. That, I will admit, was a mistaken assumption on my part. I offered to change it to something that more accurately reflected their situations. Here were some of the unapproved suggestions I made:

They were detained by local authorities…

They were taken to the police station by local authorities who were uneasy about what Braschler and Fischer might show the world.

They were taken to the police station and questioned for hours, twice after taking portraits and once after talking to protestors involved in a property dispute.

It seems that Braschler and Fischer, who were there and all, may have misunderstood exactly what was happening when the police took them down to the station and grilled them for hours about photos they had taken (twice) and their conversation with some local protestors. It was irresponsible of me to write something so blatantly biased about Chinese police without even consulting them about what happened. (I did try enlisting my editor/supervisor to help me contact the police, but she said she was too busy.)

Anyway, here is how Braschler viewed what happened to him and Fischer concerning the three arrest-like situations they found themselves in:

We’ve never been arrested before, so when we got arrested, that was quite a surprise. Particularly for us, it [photography] was just the most natural thing we did. We took a portrait of the mechanic, and the Communist leaders of a town in Liaoning took offense at us for photographing someone who wasn’t wearing proper clothes. And that was quite a shock because we didn’t expect to be arrested for something like that…

In the west if a mechanic is dirty in the evening, it means you’ve worked hard all day, and that’s OK. If you wear proper clothes, it means you’re lazy.

In Xinjiang, there, it was not such a big surprise. We photographed a railway security guy. In a way we knew it was sensitive: it’s Xinjiang, there are the problems with the Uighurs—it can happen. We kind of thought, OK, we take the risk, get arrested, and sure enough…

The really shocking one was the third one that was like a land dispute in Wuhan [in Hubei Province]. We didn’t even take out any cameras, nothing–we just talked to people. It was an area where they already have the modern high rises…and people were insisting they [residents] move out of their houses. These people saw us, they came to us, realizing this was their chance to make their call public, but in five minutes we were arrested.

It was pure intimidation. And it worked, obviously. I mean, what can you do? If they arrest you, what do you do?

I so wish I can get the police’s side of this story. It didn’t help that my supervisor took this issue up with me 30 minutes before the end of the workweek, which also happened to be my last day of this internship.

But really, all of my stories here have been biased and reflect the views of only one person or side. It’s tough to find people to interview and is a huge inconvenience to need to go through so many other people just to schedule an interview and then have it translated. Sigh. I am learning…

If you’re ever in Dandong, stay at the Crowne Plaza.

July 27th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections

A rather unfortunate fact: My favorite part about my mini-holiday to Dandong was the hotel I stayed at. Crowne Plaza Dandong was probably one of the best things I’ve ever treated myself to. This is not a slight on Dandong (the town was fun), but Beijing has been rather rough on me. I think I’ve only recently began to realize how much I needed to get away, and staying here has been one of the most pleasant outcomes for things I wasn’t expecting. In fact, I am enjoying my last few moments of Dandong at a dessert cafe in the lobby of my hotel. Here, they have rather decent (above China average) Wi-Fi and homemade ice cream. The staff is so friendly and helpful. I love our doormen, who call cabs for us twice a day, open the doors for us, and greet us upon our return with “Hui lai le, Yueh xiaojie?” I love the travel service guys who kept our bags and shoes nice and safe for us. I love the pool, accessible only through the locker room, which had amazing shampoo, conditioner and lotion (and flowers and hair dryers), and its Nemo float. I love the beds, which had pristine white down comforters and pillows. I love how clean I feel here.

And now I have to leave. I will return post-hard seat with a sore ass.

Thoughts from Dandong

July 26th, 2009 by Johanna | 1 Comment | Filed in China, Reflections

First impressions: Dandong feels like the Myrtle Beach of China, complete with waterfront seafood restaurants and an island with a small amusement park. There are bright neon lights at night, a road and walkway along the river and lots of public spaces. It is in these public spaces where Dandong comes alive. Many groups of people, young and old, gather around: to play jianzi (the Chinese hackey sack), play music, listen to music, people-watch, dance, exercise, swim, fish, catch frogs or just enjoy the night air. Walking along this riverfront drive, one finds it impossible to go more than 100 meters without stopping to watch—something.

North Korea: I saw the Ferris wheel! It looked lonely and out of place (after all, Kim Jong-il just put it there for show and didn’t intend for any North Koreans to actually enjoy it). It wasn’t lit up at night, either, but little of the DPRK was—a stark contrast to Dandong right across the Yalu River. I wonder how the North Koreans I saw through a telescope feel: envious? thankful? confused? curious?

North Koreans: North Koreans are farmers living in sad houses, as best I can tell through a telescope off the Hushan Chang Cheng (Great Wall at Tiger Mountain). I saw some again at the Duan Qiao (OK, the broken bridge), and they were playing (or washing) in the water at a really tiny beach.

North Korea, again: The landscape looks pristine and beautiful. Green mountains in the distance turn into hills that gently roll down into the river. I saw a few bicycles and, today, even a van. The country perhaps has become even more mysterious to me than before I saw it.

The road to Pyongyang: Right beside the Duan Qiao is an intact qiao, a railroad bridge. Yesterday, while we were on the Duan Qiao, a train passed by! It was exciting to see something coming in from North Korea. I couldn’t tell what kind of train it was (as in, which nation operated it), but I did see curious faces of passengers pressed against the windows. What could they have seen on the other side of the bridge? A mysterious, very backward land? Kim Jong-il’s playground? How little I know of North Korea, and here was a whole train (it was like, four cars) of people who knew firsthand…

Speaking of trains: the yinwo (hard sleeper) wasn’t bad at all. I rather liked swinging down from my top bunk, and while there was not much space to sit up, it was pretty comfortable to lie down. I’m pretty sure the 14-hour train ride went by more quickly than the 14-hour flight from JFK to PEK. I just hope the yinzuo (hard seat) won’t be too yin on my bottom.

Quick Takes: Developments

July 20th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections
  • Google music is revolutionary. I now have all the hottest and latest Chinese music (and the popular karaoke songs) so I can be that much more Asian.
  • Beijing nights are not as comfortable as they were a few weeks ago. Chilling out on my balcony before bed is impossible now.
  • They put up traffic lights at my favorite intersection. Crossing the street is no longer fun and disorderly.
  • Looks like we jinxed Beijing drivers. Auto accidents are actually quite common in China. Ever since we commented on the lack of accidents on Beijing roads, we’ve seen a few a week. Oops!

Are we tools?

July 15th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections, Work

Hung out with the foreigners from the office today after work. As usual, had very interesting conversations that provided intriguing perspectives on the motherland. Then met some more foreigners from the States who were here interning with some city planning folks. Made me wonder:

As Westerners, we tend to think of our Chinese colleagues as rather incompetent: disorganized, dysfunctional and just plain clueless. How much does work frustrate me? How often do I think that what I am handed is just plain bad journalism? How often do I think that no one knows what he’s talking about (no one knows what he’s talking about)? About every other sentence.

The city planners we met had their own complaints about Beijing’s highways and building spacing. Of course, no one is going to listen to them. The truth is, China just works, even without us Westerners meddling in their established modus operandi. It was quite astonishing to me that we even met a couple of foreigners in a random beer garden on a random street in the outskirts of the Haidian district. China is inviting so many foreigners into its bowels—and for what? Certainly not to heed our advice and knowledge. Perhaps it is in its Chinese off-handed way? But more likely, it is another case of maintaining mian zi, where China wants to appear inviting and open.

And perhaps it actually is inviting and open. China’s murky like that. It doesn’t appear to be, but you can never be quite sure. There are so many vagueries that even the Chinese can’t explain it. They are so deferential to foreigners and, yet, will never believe foreigners to be their equals in ideas and outlook. Foreigners are simply foreign, incapable of understanding. China must be the loneliest country.

Anyway. Why am I here? Can I change China for the better? Or am I simply living off the government’s auspices and getting the vacation of a lifetime for little more than helping the Chinese appear like they’re making overtures to the West?

Chinese opinion pieces

July 9th, 2009 by Johanna | No Comments | Filed in China, Reflections, Work

Here is an example of a routine polishing job:

Democracy and freedom, as essential elements of a modern civil society, have already been recognized by the Chinese government…

Recognized, though apparently not put into practice. But a little recognition can go a long way.

At any rate, the piece it comes from was written by a lecturer at Beijing University of Chemical Technology on Rebiya Kadeer.

The most frustrating thing about work is the amount of misinformation and lack of clarity in many of the stories being put out by my company. Many of the people we work with are not journalists, just translators; and I am just polishing, not editing.